twocodes.net

The living document

What changed, in its own words

The Constitution was born amendable — Article 368 built change into it on purpose. More than 100 amendments later, this is the honest picture of what was drafted, what changed, and what stands today. Keep two shelves apart: lawful amendment is the system working; the debate is only ever about whether a particular change went too far. And one doctrine stops the document from being amended out of existence — see the guardrail below.

  1. 1st Amendment · 1951 [Debated]
    As drafted

    Free speech carried no explicit limits; courts were striking down land-reform laws; special provision for backward classes was legally uncertain.

    After the amendment

    Added 'reasonable restrictions' on speech (Art 19(2)); created the Ninth Schedule to shield listed laws from judicial review; added Art 15(4), the enabling clause for reservation.

  2. 7th Amendment · 1956 [Documented]
    As drafted

    States were organised on a colonial-administrative map.

    After the amendment

    Reorganised the states on linguistic lines (the States Reorganisation Act).

  3. 24th & 25th Amendment · 1971 [Debated]
    As drafted

    After Golak Nath (1967), it was unclear whether Parliament could amend Fundamental Rights.

    After the amendment

    Affirmed Parliament's power to amend any part, including Fundamental Rights, and limited the compensation payable for acquired property — setting up the clash that Kesavananda would resolve.

  4. 26th Amendment · 1971 [Documented]
    As drafted

    Former princes drew tax-free 'privy purses' and kept royal privileges.

    After the amendment

    Abolished the privy purses and the princely privileges.

  5. 42nd Amendment · 1976 [Debated]
    As drafted

    The Preamble read 'Sovereign Democratic Republic'; judicial review was broad; there were no listed citizen duties.

    After the amendment

    The 'Mini-Constitution', passed during the Emergency: added SOCIALIST, SECULAR and 'integrity' to the Preamble; added Fundamental Duties (Art 51A); curtailed judicial review and gave Directive Principles precedence over Fundamental Rights; extended terms.

  6. 44th Amendment · 1978 [Documented]
    As drafted

    The 42nd Amendment's Emergency-era excesses were on the books; the right to property was a Fundamental Right.

    After the amendment

    Reversed much of the 42nd; restored judicial review; safeguarded the right to life and liberty (Arts 20, 21) even during emergency; and moved the right to property out of Fundamental Rights to a legal right (Art 300A).

  7. 52nd Amendment · 1985 [Documented]
    As drafted

    Elected legislators could switch parties freely ('horse-trading').

    After the amendment

    The anti-defection law (Tenth Schedule) — defectors can lose their seats.

  8. 61st Amendment · 1989 [Documented]
    As drafted

    The voting age was 21.

    After the amendment

    Lowered the voting age to 18 — millions of young citizens enfranchised.

  9. 73rd & 74th Amendment · 1992 [Documented]
    As drafted

    Local government had no constitutional footing and could be dissolved at will.

    After the amendment

    Gave constitutional status to panchayats (rural) and municipalities (urban), with regular elections and reserved seats for SC/ST and women — the silent revolution reached the village.

  10. 86th Amendment · 2002 [Documented]
    As drafted

    Education was a Directive Principle, not an enforceable right.

    After the amendment

    Made free and compulsory education for children 6–14 a Fundamental Right (Art 21A).

  11. 101st Amendment · 2016 [Documented]
    As drafted

    A tangle of separate central and state indirect taxes.

    After the amendment

    Introduced the Goods and Services Tax (GST) — one nationwide indirect tax and the GST Council.

  12. 103rd Amendment · 2019 [Debated]
    As drafted

    Reservation was for socially and educationally backward classes; the total was capped at 50%.

    After the amendment

    Added a 10% reservation for the Economically Weaker Sections of the non-reserved castes (Arts 15(6), 16(6)) — the first purely economic criterion, breaching the 50% cap. Upheld 3–2 in 2022, and genuinely contested.

Amendments tagged [Documented] are the system working; those tagged [Debated] are genuinely contested — that nuance is itself a myth-buster. A lawful amendment is not 'de-constitutionalisation'; the two belong on separate shelves. Data is editable in src/data/amendments.json. See also Method on amendment vs disinformation.